What Is a Construction Defect Claim?
A construction defect claim seeks compensation when a building has flaws in design, workmanship, materials or systems that cause damage or reduce its value, such as leaks, foundation cracks or faulty electrical work. Claims can be brought against builders, contractors, subcontractors, designers and manufacturers. Many states require written notice and a chance to repair before suing, and statutes of limitations and repose limit how long you have.
New homes and renovations can hide defects that appear months or years later. Construction defect law gives owners a path to repairs or compensation, but with strict procedural rules.
Types of defects
- Design defects: flawed plans or specifications from architects or engineers
- Workmanship defects: poor construction, such as improper flashing, framing or installation
- Material defects: defective windows, siding, pipes or roofing products
- Subsurface problems: poor soil preparation causing settling or cracks
Common results: water intrusion and mold, foundation cracks, roof leaks, HVAC and plumbing failures, and code violations.
Who may be liable
- The builder or developer
- General contractor and subcontractors
- Architects and engineers
- Material and product manufacturers
- In condominium projects, claims are often brought by the HOA on behalf of owners
Legal theories
- Breach of contract and express warranties
- Implied warranties, such as habitability or good workmanship for new homes in many states (Cornell LII)
- Negligence (Cornell LII)
- Fraud or nondisclosure
- Product liability for defective materials
Right-to-repair notice laws
Many states require owners to give the builder written notice describing the defects and an opportunity to inspect and offer repairs before filing suit. Skipping this step can delay or derail a case.
Deadlines
Two deadlines often apply:
- Statute of limitations: starts when the defect is discovered or should have been discovered.
- Statute of repose: an outer limit measured from completion of construction, after which claims are barred regardless of discovery (Cornell LII). In many states, repose periods for construction are around 10 years, but they vary.
Insurance
Builders' liability insurance may cover resulting property damage. Home warranties from builders often have their own claim procedures and limits.
Steps for owners
- Document defects with photos and dates.
- Get an independent inspection by a qualified expert.
- Review contracts, warranties and HOA documents.
- Send notice as required by your state.
- Act before deadlines.
A real estate lawyer with construction experience can evaluate the claim and experts. See also contractor disputes.
Sources
Find real estate lawyers near you
Buying or selling a home, closing on a property, or dealing with a landlord-tenant or title dispute? Compare local real estate attorneys by Google rating, reviews and office hours below.
Real Estate Lawyers by state
Tap your state to see listings by city.
This article is general legal information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws differ by state and change over time; talk to a licensed attorney in your state about your situation.