Is Mediation Worth It?
Mediation is often worth trying. A neutral mediator helps both sides negotiate, but does not decide the case, so nothing is binding unless you sign an agreement. It is usually faster and cheaper than trial, confidential in most settings, and lets the parties shape their own solution. It works less well when there is a big power imbalance, abuse, or one side will not negotiate in good faith.
Mediation is a form of alternative dispute resolution in which a neutral third party helps the parties reach a voluntary settlement (Cornell LII). Courts often require or encourage it in civil, divorce and custody cases.
How it works
- The mediator explains the process and ground rules.
- Each side may give an opening statement, together or separately.
- The mediator meets with each side privately ("caucuses") to explore interests, risks and settlement options.
- Offers go back and forth.
- If you agree, the terms are written and signed. If not, the case continues.
Benefits
- Cost: usually far cheaper than trial
- Speed: many disputes resolve in a single day
- Control: the parties decide the outcome, not a judge
- Confidentiality: statements made in mediation are generally confidential and settlement communications are generally not admissible to prove liability (FRE 408), and many states have mediation privilege laws
- Relationships: helpful for families, neighbors and businesses that will keep dealing with each other
Downsides
- No guaranteed outcome
- Costs are wasted if it fails, although it often narrows issues
- Not appropriate in some cases involving domestic violence or major power imbalances, unless safeguards are in place
- One side may use it to delay
Should you bring a lawyer?
In complex or high-stakes matters, yes, or at least consult one before signing. Lawyers help evaluate offers against likely trial results. Some family mediations are conducted without lawyers in the room, with lawyers reviewing the final agreement.
Who pays?
Parties usually split the mediator's fee unless they agree otherwise or a court orders differently. Court programs are sometimes free or low cost.
How to prepare
- Know your best and worst realistic outcomes at trial.
- Bring key documents.
- Identify your priorities and what you can trade.
- Come with authority to settle, or with decision-makers present.
What if mediation fails?
The case continues to trial or other proceedings; the mediator generally cannot report what was said. Settlement talks can continue afterward. See how long a civil lawsuit takes.
A lawyer can prepare you for mediation or review a proposed agreement.
Sources
Find lawyers & law firms near you
Compare local lawyers and law firms by Google rating, reviews and office hours below. Call two or three offices to ask about consultations, fees and experience with cases like yours before you decide.
Lawyers & Law Firms by state
Tap your state to see listings by city.
This article is general legal information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws differ by state and change over time; talk to a licensed attorney in your state about your situation.